ISO 9001 · ISO 27001 · ISO 20000 certified CERT-In aligned security audits

ETHICSCOMPUTER / JOURNAL · SEO & GROWTH MARKETING · 16 NOV 2026 · 5 MIN READ

How to Choose an SEO Company: Questions, First-Month Plan and Red Flags

What to ask an SEO agency before you sign, what a sensible first month and monthly report look like, and the red flags, from promised top rankings to bulk backlinks and accounts you do not control.

IN THIS ARTICLE (8 Sections)

An SEO company is hard to judge. Results take months, and most of the work happens where you cannot see it. That makes it easy for a weak agency to look busy and for a careful one to look slow. The way through is to judge what you can check today: the questions they answer, the access they ask for, the first month's work and the reports they send.

This guide covers each of those and ends with the red flags that should make you walk away. Several of the questions come straight from Google's own advice on hiring an SEO.

Quick answer: To choose an SEO company, ask how they will measure success in enquiries rather than rankings alone, confirm that every account stays in your name, expect a technical audit and a written plan in the first month, and insist on monthly reports built on Search Console and Analytics data. Walk away from anyone who promises a top ranking, hides their methods or sells bulk backlinks.

Decide what you are buying first

"SEO" covers several different jobs, and agencies are often good at one of them. Know which one you need before you compare proposals.

  • Technical repair: your site is slow, pages are missing from Google, or a redesign broke old links. You need technical SEO first, or content work will not help.
  • Local visibility: customers find you on Google Maps, such as a clinic, showroom or service business in one city. You need local SEO and a well-kept Google Business Profile.
  • Buyer-intent content: you sell across India or abroad, and buyers search for your product or service by name. You need pages that answer those searches and link to each other sensibly.

Then pick the number that matters to you: calls, form enquiries or store visits. Every later question is easier once you have it.

Questions to ask before you sign

Google's page on whether you need an SEO suggests several of these. Ask every agency on your shortlist the same list and compare the answers in writing.

  1. Can you show me previous work and put me in touch with a client?
  2. Do you follow Google Search Essentials?
  3. What results do you expect, in what timeframe, and how will you measure them?
  4. What experience do you have in my industry and my city?
  5. Will you share every change you make to my site?
  6. Who exactly will work on my account, and is any of it outsourced?
  7. Which accounts do you need access to, and will they stay in my name?
  8. What happens to the pages, content and accounts if we stop working together?

A good agency answers these plainly. Vague answers to questions 3, 7 and 8 usually predict vague reports later.

What a sensible first month looks like

The first month is mostly diagnosis and setup. Very little of it moves rankings, but you should be able to see every item.

  • Access in your name: Google Search Console, Google Analytics 4 and your Google Business Profile set up or verified under your own login, with the agency added as a user.
  • Conversion tracking: form submissions, calls and other enquiries recorded as conversions, so later reports can show leads and not just visits.
  • Technical crawl: broken pages, redirect chains, duplicate pages, missing canonical tags, slow pages and mobile issues, turned into a fix list in priority order.
  • Indexing check: which of your important pages Google has indexed, which it has not, and why.
  • Keyword-to-page map: each important search assigned to one page, so two of your pages do not compete for the same search.
  • Business Profile review: categories, services, hours, photos and review replies, for local businesses.
  • A written plan: which pages will be fixed, written or improved in months two and three, and in what order.

The reports you should get every month

Report itemWhere it comes fromWhy it matters
Enquiries from organic searchGoogle Analytics 4 conversions and call trackingThe number that pays for the SEO
Clicks and impressions by page and queryGoogle Search ConsoleShows which searches you actually appear for
Positions for agreed keywordsA rank tracker, cross-checked with Search ConsoleA useful trend, not the goal itself
Indexing and technical errorsGoogle Search ConsoleCatches problems before they cost traffic
Business Profile actionsGoogle Business Profile performanceCalls, direction requests and website clicks from local searches
Work done and next stepsThe agencyLets you check what you paid for

A report made only of ranking screenshots tells you very little. Rankings change with location and device, and a high position for a search nobody buys from is worth nothing. The SEO ROI calculator helps you work out what one enquiry is worth to you.

Red flags to walk away from

  • Promised top rankings: anyone who promises a first-page or top position is promising something they do not control. Google's own guidance says nobody can promise a top ranking.
  • Secret methods: they will not explain what they plan to do, or call it a proprietary technique.
  • Bulk backlinks: packages of hundreds of links, link networks or mass directory submissions. Link schemes break Google's spam policies; see black-hat vs white-hat SEO.
  • No access to your own accounts: Analytics, Search Console or your Business Profile created under the agency's login, or admin access refused.
  • Links back to them: they require a link to their site from yours. Google says you should never have to link to an SEO.
  • Cold emails with quick wins: unsolicited offers to "fix your ranking this week".
  • Pages in bulk: hundreds of near-identical city or keyword pages with only the place name changed.
  • Lock-in without exit terms: a long contract with no notice period and no handover clause.

How EthicsComputer can help

EthicsComputer's SEO services are offered as an SEO Growth Package at ₹15,000 per month with a 3-month initial commitment. It covers a technical crawl and indexing work, buyer-intent topic clusters, schema and internal linking, Google Business Profile local SEO, and a monthly conversion and keyword report. Ask us every question in this guide before you decide, and compare our answers with the other agencies on your list. Current packages are also listed on the pricing page.

Want a second opinion on an SEO proposal?

Send us your website and the proposal you are considering, and we will tell you what we would ask before signing.

About the author

Vinay Grover founded EthicsComputer in Rohtak, Haryana in 2018 and leads its cybersecurity, software and AI work for clients across India and abroad. EthicsComputer is ISO 9001, ISO/IEC 27001 and ISO 20000-1 certified.

Vinay Grover
AUTHOR

Founder & CEO of EthicsComputer (Rohtak, since 2018). Leads the company's VAPT, software architecture and AI automation work. Full profile

END OF ARTICLE

Continue exploring EthicsComputer's technical journal.

EthicsComputer assistant
EthicsComputer Assistant
Automated assistant (AI) • Team replies in office hours
⚡ Fast Response
Instant Quote & Demo
Get a Quote
Verified by SMS
Call Direct
+91 90532 10052
Direct Architect Scoping // Step 1 of 2

Request Fast Quote & Architecture SLA

Receive a preliminary project architecture, pricing tiers, and timeline estimate within 24 hours under strict NDA.

100% Mutual NDA Protected Step 1 of 2 (3 fields)

We use your phone number, company and the details you choose only to reply to your enquiry and prepare a quote. We do not sell your data. Privacy Policy · Your rights